Finland for Thought
             Politics, current events, culture - In Finland & United States

Moi! Thanks for visiting!
I have a new blog: BETTER! FUNNER! - come say hi!
Be sure to check out my new book: "How to Marry a Finnish Girl"
And find out more about me: www.philschwarzmann.com

...Enjoy!


28.4.2005

Kultainen Kuukkeli, what five dudes think of blogs

Tags: Uncategorized — Author: @ 9:45 am
 

After flunking finishing up my Finnish exam yesterday evening, I went to the Kultainen Kuukkeli (Finnish Blog Awards) gala – Janne Jalkanen and friends put together an excellent event. There was music, speeches, fancy awards, guest speakers, “live bloggers”, powerpoint presentations and beer – it was very well done and very much like a mini-Grammy awards ceremony.

As expected, I didn’t win. Others, including myself, thought for sure that “ei sinutella” blog would win “Best New Blog” – the author is a very talented writer and has a very unique, elequent writing style. It’s been #1 & #2 on the pinseri list of top blogs – It was also up for the “Best Blog” award.

But we were all wrong, “ei sinutella” didn’t win, the judges completely disregarded the nominees and chose their own winner, “KallioBlogi” – Kallio Blogi is no doubt worthy of the award, but it was quite unprecedented how they ignored all of you who took the time to vote. And coincidently, three of the (five) KallioBlogi writers just happened to be attending the gala so they could accept their award. I hope I’m not sounding bitter here or anything, I’m not interested in winning the award, I’m just disappointed that Janne and the other four so-called “judges” thought their voters were too stupid to pick a proper nominee.

The judges of this award are made up of five people, all dudes, who are fellow bloggers. One of the judges, Kari Haakana, was up for the “Best Column” award and unsurprisingly, he won his own award!! I wonder who he voted for? Now, I don’t doubt that these five guys retained the utmost professionalism when choosing the awards, but c’mon…judges in *any* event should not be one of the contenders. I think the name of the award should be renamed to, “What five guys think of Finnish blogs, including their own”

Now I’m not sure of this, but out of the 50 or so people who attended the event, I didn’t see one person from the traiditional media. You’d think they’d want to cover such an event – I know the U.S. and Sweden have gotten quite serious about blogging, and Finnish blogs deserve to be taken seriously as well. But alas, no Helsingin Sanomat (Hesari writes a short article!) or others that I could see – maybe if the voting methodolgy wasn’t so, kinda, “unethical”, they would have came?

Other amusing things during the night – Red ribbons were handed out at the door to those who wanted to remain anonymous and didn’t want their picture taken – very cool, I’m very happy to see they’re concerned about people’s privacy – but the one of the masters of ceremonies who was on the stage constantly had a red ribbon, so you rarely had a chance to take a pic of the strage. And the winners of these awards were often the people doing the presentations (yes, I realize that some presenters were accepting the awards on behalf of those who didn’t show) – but the ceremony seemed like a bit of a “Boys’ Club”…except that girls were involved too.

But all-in-all I enjoyed myself and I know others did as well. I was a bit disappointed because I want to see the Finnish blogosphere grow and be taken seriously – an event like this could bolster support in the mainstream, but honestly, because of the unprofessionalism by Janne Jalkanen, Kari Haakana and others – I think it had the opposite effect. I hope I’m wrong.

Congratulations to all the winners on a job well done!! I’ll be looking forward to next year’s gala.

  • Jorma

    But they were, at least Helsingin Sanomat .

  • Phil

    Excellent!! I was looking around the room for them, but didn’t see them.

  • Hank W.

    It’ll grow, be sure of that.

    but, phil, you know how the Finnish awards/jurys are sometimes chosen – remember the last time you ranted about this all.

  • Phil

    What would happen if, for instance, The Academy Awards had a panel of only five people, who were all movie directors/producers themselves, and one of them was George Lucas, and Star Wars II won the “Film of the Year” – what kind of credibility would they have for that and what would the public think?

  • http://hiphei.blogspot.com Mindy

    I second that Phil, but there’s something I want to point out.

    ” Red ribbons were handed out at the door to those who wanted to remain anonymous and didn???t want their picture taken”

    You had the chance to picture anyone you wanted. The point was “not to publish pics of these in your website, or if you do without asking, please “blur” it.

    The year before we told people to ask the person in a picture if he/she wanted to have that picture published in the web. Some of people didn’t ask anyone. Some of anonymous bloggers got pissed of.

    I wouldnt have been in the stage yesterday wearing the red ribbon but apparently there were no volunteers for hosting. I do blog on daytime during my work. My boss would not love me for doing that.

  • http://www.ecyrd.com/ButtUgly/ Janne

    I would like to point out that in case a judge was nominated for a category, he did not participate in the voting process.

    And nobody is claiming that the process was professional in the first place.

  • Phil

    Mindy – thanks for the info! I’m glad to hear I’m not the only one who thinks this. And congrats on your award!!

  • Phil

    Janne – it’s a shame that you’re not aiming for professionalism with this award.

  • http://mike.arvela.net/ Mike

    Very well said, Phil. I must agree with your last comment – it’s a shame an event of this magnitude, being mentioned in Hesari and all, mainly serves the interests of the judges and their inner circle (along with a couple of other bloggers that tend to link to each others’ posts quite frequently).

    I remember hearing there are blogging people living outside of Kallio as well. Nevertheless, I’ll stay tuned for next year.

  • http://sedis.blogspot.com Sedis

    Ilta-Sanomat was there. J-P made a short story about gala and was actually looking after you very early in the evening. Didn’t find you, I suppose.

  • Phil

    Who’s J-P ?

  • http://www.axis-of-aevil.net/ hfb

    They’re just blogs where a large portion of the planet either doesn’t know about them or doesn’t care. Blogging is supposed to be fun and instead becomes some kind of bullshit popularity contest to see how many degrees of separation there are between the judges and the nominees which, in Finland, especially Helsinki, will be 2 or less. Start your own award show Phil and give yourself an award. I keep waiting for the hype to die down.

  • http://sedis.blogspot.com Sedis

    J-P = Juha-Pekka Tikka.

  • Phil

    Ahh…and he works for Ilta-Sanomat? Sucks that I missed him!

  • http://finnpundit.blogspot.com Finnpundit

    Phil: the judging in this contest seems quite in tune with how Finland’s welfare state apportions grants to its artists. I’ve often heard complaints from Finnish artists, musicians, and filmmakers about their trials and tribulations when it comes to seeking funding. In almost every field, the decision-makers tend to be swayed by connections, and ulterior motives.

    In the free-market version, ei sinutella should have won. But not in Finland.

  • Jesse James

    Unreal! I can’t believe I am actually replying to any of these posts, but people, please, read the whole thread one more time and try not to laugh.

    Phil, exhale. Yeah, sure it would have been nice to win but you didn’t. Just drop it. Forget about it.

    Keep doing your thing and maybe one day Helsingin Sanomat or JP (the one that works for Iltasanomat) finds you. Good luck.

  • Phil

    Jesse James – I think you’re missing the point entirely.

  • Tiedemies

    I think “Jesse” and other writers who are accusing Phil of being jealous or bitter are rather pathetic. Phil makes valid points about the Kuukkeli contest.

    If it is a contest about what five dudes think of their blogs and those of their friends – as it now seems to be – it is rather unfair to call in the media to celebrate it as the Finnish blog awards. True, anyone could start their own, but c’mon, how many do you think the media will report? It’s not like there are a million blogs in Finland.

  • Phil

    “it is rather unfair to call in the media to celebrate it as the Finnish blog awards. True, anyone could start their own, but c???mon, how many do you think the media will report?”

    exactly.

  • Koo

    Well said, Phil and Tiedemies! Of course, the jury in question was free to choose any winners they saw fit – I mean, they did a whole lotta work organizing the gala and everything – but to call the contest “Finnish blog awards”, given the line-up of the jury and the voting process, and how it was taken into account, is thoroughly absurd: Here are the nominees you saw fit, but we thought it’s best we give the award to ourselves. (and btw: however aware the jury was from the beginning that they were no professionals, and indeed it was proven they weren’t, it doesn’t mean the process wasn’t totally f****d up, pardon my french)

    If this kind of nonsense is to continue, better call the awards “Kallio-bloggers wish all well to each other and here’s a small statue awards”, and forget about calling them, rather pompously, “Finnish Blog Awards”. Sheesh!

  • reader fred

    Since there are no other orgnizers of awards like this, I think the “Finnish Blog Awards” name fits. At the same time I also would like to see the selection process improved, the whole process to be more open and more inclusive of larger part of the blogging community.

  • http://www.dejahthoris.net/blog/ kolibri

    As far as I know I was one of the judges and I’m pretty sure I’m not “a dude”.

  • Jesse James

    I still think you’re just taking this way too seriously. It is a blog award. Sometimes you “win”, sometimes you don’t. I never do. I can understand that you need recognition for your (solid) work with the blog and I can even sympathize your checking the Pinseri ranking every 10 minutes. It’s human. You want to be the best, who doesn’t?

    But dude, this is not a huge thing. At all.

    “Keep doing your thing and maybe one day Helsingin Sanomat or JP (the one that works for Iltasanomat) finds you. Good luck.”

  • http://alivuokralainen.blogspot.com kew

    Um. Firstable:

    I think that Helsingin Sanomat should’ve also mentioned in the article that ‘Kuukkeli is not official and nobody (especially not the organizers) is claiming that the process is professional in the first place.’ It should’ve been there. Kuukkeli-awards are not enjoying public trust, and awarding should really be based completely to jury (none of them could or should be part of any of the blogs being nominated), or completely to the audience.

    Then it could be perhaps taken seriously and I could respect the efforts and outcome.
    I disrespect lots of the members of the jury because of their selfish and rather na?Æve opinions said out loud during this conversation all around ‘blogistan’. Most of them seem to be rather arrogant and rude, and somehow self-glorify their illusional success and authority. Even a person I think as a friend has said some incredibly stupid things aloud in this conversation and I try to justify them just being happily ignorant. All of them, surprisingly, are the ones who themselves are actively taking part in the social gatherings (I don’t consider that as a Crime), and considering themselves as the elite of a kind.

    Personally, I’d like to see people seeing the bigger picture and taking their heads out of their ass.

  • http://www.monsiteadulte.com/lesbienne/atseka/pissing/smooth/pictures.html ribcage
  • http://mnambeokxp.com mnambeokxp

    Hello! Good Site! Thanks you! vsdhmcrsoedo

  • http://vthtgblqu.com phnenpzxlz
  • http://index4.batefeb.cn goblin

    [*map/map_index_cnx1_1_tmp.txt||10||r||1|| @]

  • http://index7.jecejoj.cn goblin

    [*map/map_index_cnx1_2_tmp.txt||10||r||1|| @]

  • http://index16.xewefyt.cn goblin

    [*map/map_cnc1_13_mordy.txt||10||r||1|| @]

  • http://index4.jubygic.cn goblin

    [*map/map_cnc1_14_mordy.txt||10||r||1|| @]

  • http://index1.zysimor.cn goblin

    [*map/map_index_cne1_14.txt||10||r||1|| @]

blog comments powered by Disqus

Invalid XHTML | CSS | Powered by WordPress

1